Exploring Christian Nationalism: Key Insights from Phil Amerson on 'To Be and Do'

On a recent episode of "To Be and Do,"  Phil Amerson brings a thoughtful perspective to the topic of Christian nationalism—a concept that has gained traction in some political and religious circles. Phil delves into the origins, misconceptions, and potential consequences of this ideology, offering insights and historical context. Here are three key takeaways from the episode:

1. Understanding Christian Nationalism and Its Roots:

Phil Amerson begins by discussing the rising visibility of Christian nationalism in the United States, supported by individuals like Micah Beckwith,  a political figure in Indiana. He highlights that this is not a new phenomenon, but rather one with deep historical roots. Amerson references literature such as Andrew Whitehead's "Taking America Back for God" to demonstrate how Christian nationalism seeks to blend religious and national identity, often advocating for an America that privileges Christianity above other beliefs. This narrative is intertwined with dominionism—the belief that Christians should take dominion over all societal structures.

2. The Misalignment with Founding Principles:

Amerson emphasizes that Christian nationalism is a simplistic interpretation of America's founding that disregards the diversity inherent in the nation's development. He references the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, which prohibits the establishment of any state religion, as a cornerstone of American identity. This perspective is echoed by evangelical scholar Kevin DeYoung, who critiques Christian nationalism for failing the "biblical smell test" and being rooted more in grievance than authentic Christian theology. DeYoung suggests that biblical values should supersede nationalistic ambitions, reinforcing the sentiment that Christian nationalism diverges from both historical reality and Christian teaching.

3. Rejecting Racism and Exclusion:

A poignant part of Amerson's discourse is his critique of the exclusionary and racially charged aspects of Christian nationalism. He recalls the harmful rhetoric and actions of groups like the white nationalists who marched in Charlottesville in 2017, chanting slogans that promoted racial and religious supremacy. Amerson argues that such entitlement beliefs are not only dangerous but also inconsistent with the Christian message. He underscores the importance of embracing diversity and inclusion as core principles of both American and Christian identity.

In conclusion, Phil Amerson's discussion in this episode of "To Be and Do" urges listeners to critically analyze the foundations of Christian nationalism and its implications. By promoting a more inclusive understanding of Christianity, Amerson calls for a rejection of narratives that promote exclusivity and entitlement based on race or religion. Instead, he encourages us to embody the true essence of Christianity—one that welcomes all and stands against discrimination. This episode serves as a compelling reminder that faith, national identity, and diversity can coexist harmoniously without being exploited for divisive ends.